• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar

Russian Best

Russian Life & People Digest

  • Home
  • Articles
  • Questions and Answers
    • History and Politics
    • Culture and Science
    • People and Language
    • Lifestyle and Attributes
    • Russian Sports
    • Food and Drinks
    • Traveling Russia
    • Economy and Geography
    • Russian Military
    • Books & Movies
Browse: Home / History and Politics

What are some of Stalin’s actions that follow Machiavelli’s rules on how to be a dictator?

Question by Kay I: What are some of Stalin’s actions that follow Machiavelli’s rules on how to be a dictator?
Question explains all. I need to know some actions Stalin did that prove he followed Machiavelli’s rules in The Prince. Any ideas?

Answers and Views:

Answer by spiffer1
For one thing he divided those in the Committee with whom he was supposed to work.

Read all the answers in the comments.

Know better? Leave your own answer!

See other posts in History and Politics

Reader Interactions

Comments ( 1 )

  1. Spellbound says

    The Prince, the book which lays out much of Machiavelli’s ideas is not a long book, but to go through all of it, with examples from Stalin’s rule would necessitate a massive answer. I’ll outline five of Machiavelli’s ideas, the most important ones, and show how Stalin either followed, or did not follow his rules.

    “He who neglects what is done for what ought to be done, sooner effects his ruin than his preservation.” (Prince Ch. 15)
    Stalin said in 1931 that,
    “We are fifty or a hundred years behind the advanced countries. We must make good this distance in ten years. Either we do it, or we shall go under.” This was as the USSR was rapidly industrialising, and collectivising the farms. Stalin realised that to delay industrialisation was indeed to neglect what ought to be done.

    Machiavelli states that conquered territory was easy to enter, but difficult to hold: he states that the best way to hold it was to destroy the bloodline of the old ruling prince. (Ch. 4)
    Stalin did something similar in Eastern Europe when his armies liberated those countries from the Nazis. The old political elites were either decimated by arrest, trial and imprisonment, or were neutered by having their ranks, titles and influence removed – and then, exiled (mostly they fled).

    Machiavelli claims that when a prince comes to power through luck or the blessings of powerful figures within the regime, he has an easy time gaining power but a hard time keeping it. In order to maintain power, Machiavelli states that the prince must destroy those who put him in power, especially any military commanders. (Ch 7)
    Stalin did exactly that. He rose to power through cunning, luck and through the goodwill of naive comrades. He then decimated them, and the military, as it was (possibly) more loyal to Trotsky.

    A prince may be perceived to be merciful, faithful, humane, frank, and devout, but he should only SEEM to possess these qualities, as sometimes it is necessary to act against them, and even to act in an evil way on occasion. (Ch 15)
    Again Stalin seemed, to the Soviet people, to possess all these qualities (he WAS devout to the ideas of Marxism-Leninism-Stalinism), and more: he was portrayed as most wise, kind, and able to solve any problem. However, he was (as I’m sure you are aware) cruel, cunning, paranoid and vicious. And certainly he was more than capable of evil acts – some, it must be said, for the good of the USSR, such as some of his acts during WWII.

    In possibly the most famous part of the Prince, Machiavelli states that a prince should try to be loved AND feared, but, if that is not possible, it is better to be feared than loved. (Ch 17)
    Stalin WAS loved by much of the population, but amongst the politically important sections – the Communist Party, the army and the upper echelons of Soviet society – the Nomenklatura – he was feared. They all owed their positions, indeed their lives, to Stalin. A wrong word, an ill-advised look, a comment about a policy not working as planned, and they could find all their ranks, privileges and luxuries gone – or worse.

    Reply

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Primary Sidebar

Popular Posts

Pushkin's Tatiana writing a letter to Onegin

Onegin’s Tatiana Was Only Thirteen?

Russian shashlik

My Favorite Russian Food

Dacha – Home Away From Home

Subway Dog

Subway Dogs of Moscow

Cape Cod on the Rocks

What is a cocktail with vodka and cranberry juice called?

Categories

Recent Comments

  • Pat on What does Nazdrovia actually mean?
  • Ted on Where can i send free SMS messages to Russian mobiles?
  • PutinPow on What does Nazdrovia actually mean?
  • bigdogg on What does Nazdrovia actually mean?
  • HAMISH A McDONALD on What Russia would be like today if Nicholas II had not been executed?

Copyright RussianBest.com © 2025 · About · Privacy Policy · Disclaimer: RussianBest.com is an informational website, and its content does not constitute professional advice of any kind.