• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar

Russian Best

Russian Life & People Digest

  • Home
  • Articles
  • Questions and Answers
    • History and Politics
    • Culture and Science
    • People and Language
    • Lifestyle and Attributes
    • Russian Sports
    • Food and Drinks
    • Traveling Russia
    • Economy and Geography
    • Russian Military
    • Books & Movies
Browse: Home / Culture and Science

Did composer Tchaikovsky struggle with proper form?

Question by fierydog: Did Tchaikovsky struggle with proper form?
Did Tchaikovsky struggle writing music in proper form? The composer is quoted to have criticized his own ability to write in proper form. Can you give me examples using his own works that prove or disprove this? Are there some symphonies in which he has pretty good form but others he loses form altogether?

Answers and Views:

Answer by rectifier
Of course he did. If he had actually written in “proper form,” his music would have been so boring that no one today would know who he was.

Read all the answers in the comments.

What do you think?

See other posts in Culture and Science

Reader Interactions

Comments ( 5 )

  1. John says

    The introduction to his first piano concerto doesn’t appear to have anything to do with the rest of the piece.

    Overall, I am not very learned on the topic, although I would say about the 6th symphony that people clapping after the 3rd movement is quite deliberate: the fourth movement is so moving (pathetique) that it feels inappropraite to clap after it, so people clap after the 3rd instead, as it is similar to the final movement of standard symphonic form. I’ve never been to a live concert of the work, though, so I can’t comment further.

    Reply
  2. suhwahaksaeng says

    I can make a few comments both ways.

    I don’t think Tchaikovsky wrote very good development sections.
    In my opinion, the development section in his Fourth Symphony is a gosh awful mess.

    In the Pathetique Symphony, the first movement ends quietly after the exposition and restarts loudly for the development.
    This sometimes startles the audience.

    His movements in the ternary form are nice.
    In the slow movement of the Fourth Symphony and in the slow movement of his piano concerto,
    he introduces a figure in the middle section and continues that figure while restating the first section.
    He probably borrowed that idea from the slow movement in Beethoven’s Pathetique Sonata.

    The last movement from his piano concerto is in the ABABA form, which doesn’t seem to have a name.
    But so is the Chopin G major nocturne.
    I’m not saying that that’s good or bad–just a little unconventional.

    Reply
  3. erstwhile says

    Tchaikovsky never struggled with form. True, some symphonies are more coherent than others, but all seven of them are extremely fine works in their own right.

    @James: I know it’s difficult for you, but Mozart composed other pieces, not just your beloved 40th symphony.

    Reply
  4. Dave U says

    @ James
    Scott Adams said: “You can never underestimate the stupidity of the general public.”

    Reply
  5. James says

    I’ve attended live performances of his “Pathetique” symphony (No. 6 in Bm, Op. 74) and also listened to several broadcasts of live performances during which a perceptible proportion of the audience applauded after the third movement, thinking that the symphony was over. Consider that indirect evidence of Tchaikovsky’s problems with form; it’s difficult to imagine an audience thinking that a Mozart or Brahms symphony was over when it wasn’t.

    Reply

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Primary Sidebar

Popular Posts

Pushkin's Tatiana writing a letter to Onegin

Onegin’s Tatiana Was Only Thirteen?

Russian shashlik

My Favorite Russian Food

Dacha – Home Away From Home

Subway Dog

Subway Dogs of Moscow

Cape Cod on the Rocks

What is a cocktail with vodka and cranberry juice called?

Categories

Recent Comments

  • Pat on What does Nazdrovia actually mean?
  • Ted on Where can i send free SMS messages to Russian mobiles?
  • PutinPow on What does Nazdrovia actually mean?
  • bigdogg on What does Nazdrovia actually mean?
  • HAMISH A McDONALD on What Russia would be like today if Nicholas II had not been executed?

Copyright RussianBest.com © 2025 · About · Privacy Policy · Disclaimer: RussianBest.com is an informational website, and its content does not constitute professional advice of any kind.